Citizenship Regimes and Exclusion: Historical Analysis of Legislation on Illegalized Migration in the US
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Citizenship regimes are institutionalized systems of formal and informal norms that define access to membership, as well as associated rights and duties. This paper studies illegalized migration as one of the major tests to assess whether citizenship regimes are fair institutions, based on a historical analysis of legislation meant to reduce illegalized migration in the United States between 1995 and 2022. We build our empirical research starting from a simple observation: despite the great number of bills introduced to reduce illegalized migration to the US, most of such initiatives fail to become law. In fact, 93.5% of all immigration initiatives did not even pass the chamber of Congress in which they were originally presented. Such a high rate of failure shows that these proposals are motivated by electoral aspirations, rather than coming from a genuine wish to help migrants or grant them citizenship. Furthermore, there is also an economic interest that justifies the maintenance of low-cost disposable immigrant labor, with no right to citizenship. Our analysis is an example of how state regulation processes seem to work to formalize, rather than alleviate or eradicate, the precarious legal statuses of illegalized migrants. We conclude that a globalized phenomenon such as citizenship requires going beyond merely institutional and formal conceptions. We need to rethink the institutional notion of citizenship, as a merely status held under the authority of a state and consider it from a cosmopolitan perspective and a multilateral basis. But as long as citizenship remains under the responsibility of states, illegalized migrants will continue to experience precarious citizenship.
Article Details
Uso de licencias Creative Commons (CC)
Todos los textos publicados por Problema. Anuario de Filosofía y Teoría del Derecho sin excepción, se distribuyen amparados bajo la licencia CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 Internacional; que permite a terceros utilizar lo publicado, siempre que mencionen la autoría del trabajo y a la primera publicación en este Anuario.
Accesibilidad a los artículos y demás publicaciones de manera total o parcial bajo el concepto de copia, distribución, comunicación pública, acceso interactivo (por internet u otros medios), manteniendo de manera explícita el reconocimiento al autor o autores y a la propia revista (reconocimiento de autoría).
Advertencia de que si se remezcla, modifican los artículos o se emplean fragmentos en otras creaciones, no se puede distribuir el material modificado, ni tampoco se permite reconstruir versiones a partir de los artículos originales publicados (obras derivadas).
Se prohíbe el uso de contenidos de los artículos publicados, total o parcialmente, con fines lucrativos (reconocimiento no comercial).
Consúltese https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
References
Bauder, H. (2014). Why we Should Use the Term “Illegalized” Refugee or Immigrant: A Commentary. International Journal of Refugee Law, 26(3), 327-332.
Bean, F. D. & Lowell, B. L. (2007). Unauthorized Migration. In M. C. Waters & R. Ueda (Eds.), The New Americans, A Guide to Immigration Since 1965 (pp. 70-82). Harvard University Press.
Bellamy, R. (2008). Citizenship: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press.
Bustamante, J. (2007, December 23). Gracias a ACLU y MALDEF. Reforma.
Brubaker, R. (1992). Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany. Harvard University Press.
Castles, S. (2010). Migración irregular: causas, tipos y dimensiones regionales. Migración y Desarrollo, 8(15), 49-80.
CNN Library. (2018). 1998 US Embassies in Africa Bombings Fast Facts. CNN, July 31, 2018. In Department of Homeland Security-U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, “Consideration of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA)”, 2012. https://www.uscis.gov/archive/consideration-deferred-action-childhood-arrivals-daca, Revised on September 30, 2018.
Düvell, F. (2008). Clandestine Migration in Europe. Social Science Information, 47(4), 479-497.
Falk, F. (2010) Invasion, Infection, Invisibility: An Iconology of Illegalized Immigration. In C. Bischoff, F. Falk & S. Kafehsy (Eds.), Images of Illegalized Immigration. Towards a Critical Iconology of Politics (pp. 83-99). Transcript Verlag.
Gallup. (2019, February 13). “In Depth: Topics A To Z: Immigration”. https://news.gallup.com/poll/1660/immigration.aspx
Gallie, W. B. (1995-1956). Essentially Contested Concepts. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 56, 167-198.
Gianni, M. (2021). Normative Perspectives on Citizenship and Migration: The Challenge of Integration into Citizenship in Immigration Societies. In M. Giugni & M. Grasso (Eds.), Handbook of Citizenship and Migration (pp. 21-36). Elgar Handbooks in Migration.
Giugni, M. & M. Grasso. (2021). Citizenship and Migration: Mapping the Terrain. In M. Giugni & M. Grasso (Eds.). Handbook of Citizenship and Migration (pp. 1-19). Elgar Handbooks in Migration.
Guillaume, X. (2014). Regimes of Citizenship. In E. Isin & P. Nyers (Eds.), Routledge Handbook of Global Citizenship Studies (pp. 150-158). Routledge.
Guerra, B. B. & Levine, E. (2014). Biopolítica y bioeconomía de la reforma migratoria en Estados Unidos. Carta Económica Regional, 114.
Hipsman, F. & D. Meissner (2013). Immigration in the United States: New Economic, Social, Political Landscapes with Legislative Reform on the Horizon. Migration Policy Institute, Migration Policy Source, Migration Policy Institute, https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/immigration-united-states-new-economic-social-political-landscapes-legislative-reform# Revised on December 15, 2019. https://edition.cnn.com/2013/10/06/world/africa/africa-embassy-bombings-fast-facts/index.html. Revised on December 19, 2018.
Isin, E. & P. Nyers (2014). Introduction. Globalizing Citizenship Studies. In E. Isin & P. Nyers (Eds.), Routledge Handbook of Global Citizenship Studies (pp. 1-11). Routledge.
Isin, E. & Turner, B. (2002). Citizenship Studies: An Introduction. In E. Isin and B. Turner (Eds.). Handbook of Citizenship Studies (pp. 1-10). Sage.
Keeter, S. (2009). Where the Public Stands on Immigration Reform. Pew Research Center.
Krogstad, J. M., Passel, J. S. & Cohn, D. (2019). 5 Facts about illegal immigration in the US. Pew Research Center.
Lori, N. (2017). Statelessness, “In-Between” Statuses, and Precarious Citizenship. In A. Shachar, R. Bauböck, I. Bloemraad & M. Vink (Eds.). The Oxford Handbook of Citizenship (pp. 743-767). Oxford University Press.
Massey, Douglas S. (1995). The New Immigration and Ethnicity in the United States, Population and Development Review, 631-652.
Meissner, Doris M. et al. (2013). Immigration enforcement in the United States: The Rise of a Formidable Machinery. Migration Policy Institute.
Miller, D. (2016). Strangers in our Midst: The Political Philosophy of Immigration. Harvard University Press.
Ngai, M. M. (2014). Impossible Subjects. Princeton University Press.
Orrenius, P. & Zavodny, M. (2016). Irregular Immigration in the European Union. FRB of Dallas Working Paper No. 1603, 1-29.
Paik, A. N. (2020). Bans, Walls, Raids, Sanctuary: Understanding US Immigration for the Twenty-First Century. Univ of California Press.
Papademetriou, D. G., O’Neil, K. & Jachimowicz, M. (2004). Observations on Regularization and the Labor Market Performance of Unauthorized and Regularized Immigrants. EC, DG Employment and Social Affairs.
Peutz, N. & Genova, N. de. (2010). The Deportation Regime: Sovereignty, Space, and the Freedom of Movement.
Pew Research Center (2009, January 22). Economic, Jobs Trumps all other Policy Priorities in 2009, Environment, Immigration, Health Care Slip Down the List. https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2009/01/22/economy-jobs-trump-all-other-policy-priorities-in-2009/
Pew Research Center (2022, February). Public’s Top Priority for 2022: Strengthening the Nation’s Economy. https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2022/02/16/publics-top-priority-for-2022-strengthening-the-nations-economy/
Roche, M. (2002). Social Citizenship: Grounds of Social Change. In E. Isin & B. Turner (Eds.), Handbook of Citizenship Studies (pp. 69-86). Sage.
Rosentiel, T. (2007). Mixed Views on Immigration Bill, Democratic Leaders Face Growing Disapproval, Criticism on Iraq. Pew Research Center. Revised on February 17, 2022. https://www.pewresearch.org/2007/06/07/mixed-views-on-immigration-bill/
Shachar, A. (2011). Picking Winners: Olympic Citizenship and the Global Race for Talent. The Yale Law Journal, 120, 2088-2139.
Schudel, M. (2013, October 18). C. W. Bill Young, Longtime Fla. Congressman, Dies at 82, The Washington Post. Revised on December 13, 2018. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/cw-bill-young-longtime-fla-congressman-dies-at-82/2013/10/18/817fdc10-3845-11e3-ae46-e4248e75c8ea_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.24567ee0c7fa
Smith, L. (2018). Lamar Smith Personal Website. Revised on December 19, 2018. https://www.texansforlamarsmith.com/lamar-smiths-proven-conservative-record
Soysal, Y. (1994). Limits of Citizenship: Migrants and Postnational Membership in Europe. The University of Chicago Press.
Swerts, Th. (2014). Non-Citizen Citizenship in Canada and the United States. In E. Isin & P. Nyers (Eds.), Routledge Handbook of Global Citizenship Studies (pp. 295-304). Routledge.
Torre Cantalapiedra, E. (2015). Hacia un marco analítico explicativo de las políticas de los Estados de la Unión Americana respecto a la inmigración indocumentada. Foro Internacional, 55(4), 1139-1164.
US Congress. (2018a). Información de Representantes. Revised on December 19, 2018. https://www.congress.gov/member/c-w-young/Y000031?q=%7b%22search%22:%5b%22H.R.3610%22%5d%7d&r=14&pageSort=dateOfIntroduction%3Adesc y http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/biodisplay.pl?index=Y000031
US Congress. (2018b). Congreso de Estados Unidos, Información de Representantes. Revised on December 19, 2018. http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/biodisplay.pl?index=S000583 y https://www.congress.gov/member/lamar-smith/S000583?q=%7B%22search%22%3A%5B%22immigration%22%5D%7D&r=6
US Congress. (2000). Expresses the Sense of Congress that the Attorney General, in Consultation with the Secretaries of State, Commerce, and the Treasury should Consult with Affected foreign Governments to Improve Border Management. Revised on December 19, 2018. https://www.congress.gov/bill/106th-congress/house-bill/4489?q=%7B%22search%22%3A%5B%22H.R.4489%22%5D%7D&r=1&s=3
US Congress (2020), Members. Revised on March 1, 2020. https://www.congress.gov/member/patrick-leahy/L000174?searchResultViewType=expanded&KWICView=false
Villaseñor, R. & Acevedo, L. (2009). La actividad legislativa estatal vinculada con la inmigración y los inmigrantes en Estados Unidos. In P. Leite & S. Giorguli (Coords.), El estado de la migración. Las políticas públicas ante los retos de la migración mexicana en Estados Unidos (pp. 415-438). Consejo Nacional de Población.
Vink, M. (2017). Comparing Citizenship Regimes. In A. Shachar, R. Bauböck, I. Bloemraad & M. Vink (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Citizenship (pp. 221-244). Oxford University Press.
Walters, W. (2002). Deportation, Expulsion, and the International Police of Aliens, Citizenship Studies, 6(3), 265-292.
Walzer, M. (1983). Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality. Perseus Books.
